When I was a very young and naïve Apricot, I could be quite outspoken and unkind. My mother would often correct me with the gentle but firm reminder: “You must not say that because it is mean and hurtful.” Once the red mist had cleared from our eyes, she would sit me down and explain why my words had been harsh or unpleasant. Sometimes I understood immediately; other times I argued my case. But eventually the lesson sank in: words can wound as easily as sticks and stones, and what we say or write can feel like a WMD — a “Weapon of Mass Destruction.” Remember that phrase? Very much “in vogue” a few decades ago.
One of the hallmarks of our present age is the cry for “Freedom of Speech.” Yet if I correct someone because I feel they are expressing something unkind, I am told I am infringing their right to free expression… and they can “cancel me.” The irony, of course, is that in defending their freedom, they can remove mine. Whatever “cancel” means these days.
I agree wholeheartedly that freedom of speech is a basic human right and one that must be protected. But it is also a delicacy — easily bruised, easily abused, and often used in ways that diminish rather than elevate. I think we are seeing some of that in our “western, so‑called cultured” world today.
So, what does the Church actually say about freedom of speech? Does it allow it?
I asked Artificial Intelligence — and the answer is quite neat:
“The Catholic Church teaches that freedom of speech is rooted in the dignity of the human person, but it is never an absolute licence to say anything without regard for truth or the good of others. The Catechism of the Catholic Church affirms that human beings ‘have the right to act in conscience and in freedom’ (CCC 1782), yet it also insists that communication must always respect truth, charity, and justice (CCC 2471–2472). The Church warns against speech that harms others through falsehood, detraction, or calumny (CCC 2477–2479), and emphasises that the right to express one’s thoughts carries ‘responsibilities and limits’ for the sake of the common good (Pacem in Terris, 12). Vatican II teaches that society should safeguard the right to seek and express truth, but always in a way that upholds human dignity and promotes the moral order (Dignitatis Humanae, 2). In this vision, authentic freedom of speech is not merely the ability to speak, but the responsibility to use speech in service of truth, justice, and the flourishing of all.”
In our world of legitimised insults and permitted degradation of migrants and political opponents, the words used by some “freedom of speech” advocates do not promote human dignity or the moral order. Instead, they echo the tantrums of toddlers who still need to learn that local and global problems are not solved by shouting louder, but by seeking truth, justice, and the flourishing of all.
How is this learned? By the age-old crafts of respect, discussion and diplomacy.
Not bullying….not “cancelling”.
Some of us might need to grow up and remember the advice of our parents and teachers!

